If you find yourself constantly fluffing your pillow throughout the night in a futile attempt to find comfort, it might be time for an upgrade. Selecting the right Organic Pillows For Side Sleepers is a highly individualized choice and can significantly impact the quality of your sleep. Your preferred sleep position should guide your decision: thick and firm pillows suit side sleepers, while soft and thinner ones are preferable for stomach sleepers, with back sleepers benefiting from a middle-ground option.
At the Good Housekeeping Institute Textiles Lab, a team of fiber scientists and engineers has rigorously tested over 160 pillows, analyzing more than 5,000 data points to identify the ideal pillow for each type of sleeper. These experts assess factors like durability, washability, and pillowcase compatibility in the lab, while feedback from at-home testers contributes insights on comfort, support, temperature regulation, and other important considerations.
BEST OVERALL PILLOW: Coop Home Goods Original Loft Pillow
The Coop Home Goods pillow caters to all sleeping positions, thanks to its adjustable fill that allows you to customize the height according to your preferences. Its hybrid design, blending foam and fiberfill, makes it an excellent choice for those uncertain about which type of pillow to choose.
Combining the qualities of softness and firmness, this pillow is filled with a blend of memory foam pieces and microfiber clusters, providing both support and plushness simultaneously. Despite many top-rated pillows costing over $100, this option offers great value. However, adjusting the fill to achieve your desired height may be a bit messy, requiring caution and not something you’d want to do frequently.
It’s conveniently machine washable for easy maintenance and resilience, bouncing back to shape after undergoing pressure tests in our lab. With over 57,000 reviews and an average 4.5-star rating on Amazon, it’s a best-seller, lauded as the “best pillow ever” by users. For hot sleepers, the brand’s Eden pillow offers the same construction but includes cooling gel in the memory foam.
Feedback from our at-home testers unanimously praised the pillow, reporting improvements in sleep quality compared to their previous pillows. This is a best Organic Pillows For Side Sleepers. One tester described it as “wrapping around my head, allowing me to sink into it,” while another noted being “able to switch comfortably between side, back, and stomach sleeping positions while feeling supported and comfortable.”
BEST VALUE PILLOW: Amazon Basics Down-Alternative Pillows Two-Pack
This pillow from Amazon’s brand offers exceptional value for money: Sold in pairs, it outperforms other styles on the market, even those priced at over three times its cost in our tests. Despite its affordability, the polyester down-alternative fill ensures durability and maintains its shape even after washing, eliminating concerns about shrinkage or deterioration.
Available in two firmness levels, the softer option is well-suited for stomach or back sleepers, making it also suitable for children who require a lower profile to match their smaller frames. The medium firmness option is tailored for side and back sleepers, although individuals with larger frames may find it lacking in the necessary support.
Feedback from testers highlighted the pillow’s softness, with one user expressing appreciation for its fluffiness and ability to maintain its shape over time. While some desired a taller and denser pillow, they still awarded it high scores for preventing morning soreness.
BEST PILLOW FOR SIDE SLEEPERS: Pillow Cube Side Cube Pro
This pillow is designed specifically for side sleepers. If you consistently sleep on your side, it could provide excellent support. However, if you tend to switch positions during the night, it may not offer the same level of comfort.
Ideal for side sleepers seeking optimal alignment, this pillow features a unique shape that maintains consistent thickness, unlike traditional pillows. It fills the space between your shoulder and neck, promoting better sleep posture. Available in three heights, with the standard option being the most popular, it caters to individuals ranging from 5’3″ to 6’4″ in height.
For added convenience, Pillow Cube offers a stretchy pillowcase crafted from polyester and spandex, specifically designed to snugly fit this pillow. While you can still use a regular pillowcase if preferred, it may not provide as precise a fit. Additionally, for those prone to overheating during sleep, the Ice Cube version of this pillow features an outer cover with a cooling sensation.
According to testers, the Side Cube Pro significantly improved their alignment. One remarked, “It cradles my head perfectly,” while another noted, “My neck feels fully supported.” However, it’s worth noting that this pillow is best suited for dedicated side sleepers, as it may feel too tall for individuals who switch positions frequently, such as those who also sleep on their stomachs or backs.
BEST PILLOW FOR STOMACH AND BACK SLEEPERS: Layla Kapok Pillow
For those who desire a plush pillow feel without compromising on support, this option is ideal. Its gentle softness and lower profile make it suitable for side, back, or combination sleepers.
Featuring an unparalleled level of comfort, this pillow surprised us with its plushness while still providing ample support. This is achieved through its innovative blend of shredded memory foam and soft, fluffy kapok—a natural fiber akin to cotton but with a silkier feel. The fill is adjustable, accommodating various sleep styles and individuals who frequently change positions throughout the night.
While its softer texture makes it particularly suitable for stomach and back sleepers and Organic Pillows For Side Sleepers, preventing neck tilting often associated with firmer pillows, it maintains resilience. In our tests, it readily regained its shape after bearing weight to simulate overnight use. It’s worth noting that the pillow’s outer cover features a grey pattern, which may show through white pillowcases.
Testers unanimously praised this pillow, awarding it top marks for comfort, support, and overall satisfaction. They noted its ability to retain shape and alleviate morning soreness. One tester even remarked on replacing two pillows with this single option, while another appreciated its softness, supportiveness, and moldable nature.
BEST FOAM PILLOW: Tuft & Needle Premium Foam Pillow
For those who prefer the supportive and contouring feel of dense, solid foam over softer foam clusters, this option is ideal. Despite leaning towards the firmer side, it maintains a comfortable feel without being overly hard.
Tuft & Needle employs solid foam rather than foam clusters to provide a more supportive surface, enhanced by ventilated holes for breathability, along with graphite and cooling gel to prevent overheating. Described by the brand as “squishy while remaining supportive,” we wholeheartedly agree based on our assessments.
In laboratory tests, it promptly regained its shape after pressure was applied. While it fits reasonably well into a pillowcase, it’s slightly smaller than some other pillows, resulting in a slightly loose fit. Although only the cover is machine washable, we found that it laundered well without any shrinkage.
Testers lauded this pillow as a top-rated choice, awarding it perfect scores for comfort and shape retention. Universally, testers expressed that it felt like an upgrade from their usual pillows. Comments praised its firmness while maintaining a soft overall feel, noting its comfort across various sleeping positions and its optimal level of firmness.
